Welcome to our new website!
1001 Heroes, Legends, Histories & Mysteries Podcast
1001 Heroes, Legends, Histories & Mysteries Podcast
Where History Comes Alive! A fast-paced, well-researched weekly podcast covering a wide range of historical events, persons, places, legends, and mysteries, Hosted by Jon Hagadorn, the selection of stories and interviews includes lost treasure, unsolved mysteries, unexplained phenomenon, WWII stories, biographies, disasters, legends of the Old West, American Revolutionary history, urban legends, movie backstories, and much more. Available wherever podcasts are found, including Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Comcast & others. Episodes air Sundays at 12pm ET and "Best Ofs" on Fridays early around 12:05 AM. Easiest way to search categories or leave a review is at our website here: https://www.bestof1001stories.com/show/1001-heroes-legends-histories-mysteries-podcast/ Follow us at www.Facebook.com/1001Heroes and Twitter @1001podcast.
Choose your favorite podcast player
July 31, 2026

TRUE CRIME/URBAN LEGEND THE LEGEND OF REHMEYER'S HOLLOW

TRUE CRIME/URBAN LEGEND THE LEGEND OF REHMEYER'S HOLLOW
Download episode
Legends And Urban Legends Crimes Stories

⭐ 1001 Heroes: THE LEGEND OF REHMEYER’S HOLLOW — Show Notes

Episode Summary

Deep in the farmlands of York County, Pennsylvania lies a patch of ground long whispered about in hushed tones—Rehmeyer’s Hollow, a place where folklore, fear, and frontier‑era folk magic collided in one of the strangest true stories ever recorded. This episode explores the life and death of Nelson Rehmeyer, a local “powwow doctor,” and the chain of events that turned a quiet rural hollow into a national headline and a permanent fixture of American supernatural lore.

What You’ll Hear in This Episode

  • The Pennsylvania Dutch tradition of “powwow” magic—a blend of faith healing, charms, and centuries‑old rituals brought to America by German settlers.

  • Nelson Rehmeyer’s role as a healer, and why some neighbors believed he possessed powers that could cure—or curse.

  • The paranoia of John Blymire, a man convinced he was under a supernatural spell and desperate to break it.

  • The fateful night of 1928, when Blymire and two accomplices entered Rehmeyer’s home seeking to destroy the source of the supposed curse.

  • The aftermath, including the sensational trial that shocked the nation and cemented Rehmeyer’s Hollow as one of America’s most enduring “hex murder” legends.

  • The legacy, from ghost stories and tourist curiosity to the cultural impact of powwow magic on Pennsylvania folklore.

Why This Story Matters

Rehmeyer’s Hollow is more than a ghost tale—it’s a window into:

  • The power of belief and how fear can override reason.

  • The collision of old‑world traditions with modern American life.

  • A community grappling with superstition, identity, and tragedy.

  • The way folklore evolves into legend, and legend into cultural memory.

Key Themes

  • Folk magic & superstition

  • Rural American folklore

  • Crime driven by belief

  • Pennsylvania Dutch culture

  • The psychology of fear

Perfect For Listeners Who Enjoy

  • True supernatural legends

  • Historical mysteries

  • Folklore‑based crime stories

  • Atmospheric storytelling with deep regional roots

Additional Resources

  • Historical accounts of the 1928 Hex Murder

  • Background on Pennsylvania Dutch powwow traditions

  • Local York County folklore archives

About 1001 Heroes

1001 Heroes, Legends, Histories & Mysteries brings you gripping true stories from America and beyond—tales of courage, tragedy, folklore, and the extraordinary people who shaped our world.